So, in case you haven’t heard, Disney decided that the covers already out there for Nightmare Before Christmas would be a great way to make some money. But instead of using those covers, they hunted down their own.
I love this damn movie. And not recently. I loved it when it was in theaters and I was but a wee child. I was spooky from a young age.
I’ll give you a quick rundown.
Overture(DeVotchKa)
Pretty straight-faced playthrough, nothing too wild or out there. I didn’t get the feel for the cover artist, just more Nightmare stuff. Still, not bad. Listenable.
Opening (Danny Elfman)
Not technically revisiting, is it? This is all ground he’s ploughed before. Cheating. Let’s move on.
This Is Halloween (Marylin Manson)
This is an old cover. If you haven’t heard it by now, you lose at the internet. Still, it’s solid. Say what you will about Marylin Manson, he knows what songs to cover. Another solid version of this is offered up by Panic at the Disco.
Jack’s Lament (All American Rejects)
Now, understand, this is my favorite song of the movie. I absolutely adore it. So when I hear that whiny voice streak through my eardrum, I wail inside. I got 20 seconds into this song before I had to turn it off, and only 4 seconds of that was comprised of vocals. Next.
Docter Finkelstein/In the Forest (Amina)
Thus far, the instrumentals are two-for-two on being good, and this one takes a step outside of what Nightmare originally laid out for it. I think this one’s quite well done. Loving the theramin.
What’s This? (Flyleaf)
Ugh. So, instrumentals are winning, but vocal bits are just… not clearing it. Her vocals are not quite emotive enough to handle the wonder that is supposed to be coursing through this song. She sings “What’s this?” but it sounds like she really couldn’t care less about what anything is.
I never in my life thought I’d write these words, but Fallout Boy did it better. You have failed. Next.
Town Meeting Song (The Polphonic Spree)
Let me just get this out of the way: I love The Polyphonic Spree. And their absolutely inspired cover of Nirvana’s Lithium made me very curious to hear this. I’m really enjoying this one. It’s not what I expected, but it’s doing it’s thing and taking me along with it. Best of the vocal songs so far. My only real complaint is that it needs to pick up the pace.
Jack and Sally Montage (The Vitamin String Quartet)
Another instrumental. Rather meh. Doesn’t entice, doesn’t push away. It’s just there, four people on string instruments playing some music that stays just this side of spooky.
Jack’s Obsession (Sparklehorse)
I didn’t know you could ruin this song this badly. After all, it’s a bit more obscure, and doesn’t draw as much love or notice as the others. I thought this would slip under the radar of suck. I was wrong.
Kidnap the Sandy Claws (Korn)
It’s Korn. I don’t think I have to say any more. I started laughing at this cover not ten seconds in. I’d much rather be listening to She Wants Revenge, and even I’m able to recognize that SWR didn’t do that amazing of a cover.
Making Christmas (Rise Against)
Not horrible, but the vocals just do not work for this song.
I’ve started down this dark path, and I will finish. Not rain, nor snow, nor sleet, nor hail will stop me from this crap. But good God, what have I condemned myself to?
Nabbed (Yoshida Brothers)
More instrumental. More delicious things-not-sucking. Seriously, I could take half those singers to school on how you do these songs, and I’m barely passable. This track is great, really divergent from the original, displaying the Yoshida Brothers for what they are, but still keeps that kick of what the song once was.
Oogie Boogie’s Song (Rodrigo y Gabriela)
So, wow. First, whatever made Disney decide to pick up these two is beyond me, but for once, God bless ‘em for making a good call. This was a wonderful cover, even if you don’t like two guitars playing maniacally side-by-side (which really, if you don’t, what’s your problem?). Gabriela’s standard percussion-style strumming and Rodrigo’s sharp picking make for an amazing cover here.
Sally’s Song (Amy Lee)
When I first saw who was singing this, I muttered “Goddamnit.” She has a solid voice, but it’s so typical, putting the lead singer of Evanescence on this kind of project. Still. She did a very solid job, and I really can’t complain. It doesn’t compete with Fiona Apple’s version at all. I think the two bring their own things to the table, and shouldn’t have to fight for the lead.
Christmas Eve Montage (RJD2)
Meh.
Poor Jack (Plain White T’s)
First of all… what? The Hey-There-Delilah assholes covering Nightmare Before Christmas music? And… wow. This… isn’t terrible. Crap. Have my standards fallen so low that this is good, or is it good on its own?
To the Rescue (Datarock)
The first few measures of standard uhn-tiss made me concerned. Largely, not bad, but not incredible. Feels like that’s become the mantra of this CD (alongside “singers can’t sing”).
Finale/Reprise (Shiny Toy Guns)
And welcome to why I’m here. Hearing this is a terrible tease. It makes me want to hear them cover the whole album. I can only imagine how they’d kick ass at What’s This, Sally’s Song (though I’d wager Carah would swing it better than Sisley). Ah, well. Damn.
Closing (Danny Elfman)
Cheating.
End Title (The Album Leaf)
Maybe we go through a lot of suck, but this is prettymuch the best way to wrap up this CD.
In the end? I’d say don’t buy it, just download the good tracks.